Soapbox Engage Blog

Of the various solutions in your nonprofit’s software toolkit, your donor database (also known as a constituent relationship management system or CRM) is arguably the most vital to your fundraising work. It holds a wealth of information about your supporters that allows you to engage them effectively, maximize your revenue generation potential, and ultimately make a bigger difference in your community.

However, your CRM will only provide these benefits if you leverage it strategically. While there are some generally applicable ways to make this solution work for you, each organization is unique and requires an approach to database management tailored to its needs and goals.

In this guide, we’ll review four best practices for optimizing your donor database that you can use as a starting point for your strategy. Let’s dive in!

4 Best Practices for Optimizing Your Nonprofit Database

1. Create Detailed Donor Profiles
2. Practice Good Data Hygiene
3. Connect Your Database to Other Software Solutions
4. Track and Analyze Key Metrics

1. Create Detailed Donor Profiles

One of the most essential features of any good nonprofit CRM is the ability to create profiles for each individual supporter. According to DonorSearch, a donor profile is “a digital resource that tracks all of the key information about a current nonprofit donor or…prospect. Organizations typically gather this information from prospect research, direct communication with the donor, and data on their ongoing engagement with the nonprofit.”

To develop comprehensive, actionable donor profiles, include the following sections and data points in each one:

• Basic details: Full and preferred name, pronouns, date of birth, phone number, email address, mailing address, preferred communication method.
• Personal history: Alma mater, degree(s) earned, connections to foundations, real estate holdings, public stock holdings, community involvement, interests and values.
• Familial information: Marital status; spouse’s name, professional affiliations, and philanthropic ties (if applicable); details on children (if applicable); other key relatives.
• Professional affiliations: Current employer, position, years with employer, work contact information, employment history, relevant business contacts.
• Connections to your organization: Giving history (number of donations, frequency, recency, average gift amount, lifetime value), volunteer engagement, event attendance, board service.
• External philanthropic ties: Charitable giving, volunteering, event attendance, and board service with other organizations.

Treat your nonprofit’s donor profiles as living documents. As you learn new details about current and prospective supporters through research, cultivation activities, or their involvement with your organization, promptly update their profiles. This way, you can always reference the most accurate and recent information about a donor when developing an engagement strategy for them.

2. Practice Good Data Hygiene

Data hygiene is the process of maintaining a “clean” database. When you clean your nonprofit’s CRM, you verify, update, and purge information to ensure all of your records are current and accurate. By contrast, a “dirty” database contains outdated, incomplete, incorrect, or duplicated information that can lead your organization astray as you try to make data-driven decisions.

Double the Donation’s data hygiene guide offers the following best practices for nonprofit database maintenance:

• Audit your database. During an audit, you’ll survey your CRM to identify any inaccuracies, consolidate information into an organized system, and consider your data hygiene efforts in light of your organization’s overarching priorities.
• Assign data responsibilities. Put someone in charge of overseeing all data hygiene efforts, then delegate more specific tasks to various team members who have the bandwidth and expertise to perform them effectively.
• Re-evaluate your data collection strategy. Focus on tracking metrics that are relevant to your current priorities, then organize your database so it’s easy to locate and analyze that information.
• Develop data standards. These are essentially rules that ensure all staff members input data the same way. For example, when entering supporters’ mailing addresses, specify whether your team should use common abbreviations like “St.” and “Apt.” or spell out “Street” and “Apartment.”
• Continuously update and validate your data. Use third-party research, surveys, or data appending services to assist in this process.

Train your team in these best practices to ensure everyone is on the same page about the correct ways to enter, update, and share data throughout your organization.

3. Connect Your Database to Other Software Solutions

Generally speaking, the better integrated your nonprofit’s software is, the easier it is to transfer data between solutions. Automating this process via integrations saves your team time and reduces the potential for human error that comes along with manual data entry.

Whenever possible, connect your donor database to your nonprofit’s other core software solutions, such as your:

• Online donation platform to automatically update donors’ giving history every time they contribute.
• Corporate giving software to track which of your donors take advantage of their employers’ workplace giving programs, like matching gifts and volunteer grants.
• Marketing tools to easily send targeted messages to different segments of your audience and monitor interactions with digital communications.
• Accounting system to ensure your organization’s records and reports accurately reflect your contribution data.
• Prospect research database to populate potential high-impact donors’ profiles with the necessary information on their wealth and philanthropic history for effective major gift solicitation.

If you’re considering investing in a new solution in any of these categories, look for a tool that integrates with your existing CRM. Check the new platform’s website for a list of database integrations or ask about them during your demo before making your final decision.

4. Track and Analyze Key Metrics

Most high-quality nonprofit databases have analytics and reporting capabilities. Use these tools to evaluate metrics related to your organization’s fundraising and donor engagement goals, including:

• Total revenue raised per year, per donor segment, and per campaign.
• Average gift amounts across your entire organization and for each giving tier (small, mid-level, and major donors).
• Donor acquisition rates holistically and via specific initiatives.
• Donor retention rates year-over-year and campaign-to-campaign.
• Donor lifetime values to see how much each individual supporter is worth to your nonprofit.

Generate visualizations of these metrics in your database so it’s easy for your team to see your organization’s progress and draw actionable conclusions from your data.

---

Your nonprofit’s CRM is essential to your operations, donor engagement efforts, and ability to further your mission. As you implement the tips above, remember to adapt your strategy as needed so your optimized database serves your organization’s unique needs and goals.